Yorkshire 1st innings
WH Woolhouse                             b F Pilch             12
G Hattersley                             b Daplyn               4
J Dearman             c Laws                                   46
T Marsden                                b Spinks              17
E Vincent             st W Roberts                             32
G Smith               c W Roberts                              15
J McCoy                                  b W Pilch              0
G Rawlins                                b W Pilch              4
J Woollen             c Hogg                                    4
J Hydes                                  b W Pilch             19
F Barlow              not out                                  11
Extras                (b 12, w 15)                             27
Total                 (all out, 110 overs)                    191

FoW: 1-4, 2-?, 3-?, 4-?, 5-?, 6-?, 7-?, 8-?, 9-?, 10-191.

Bowling                      O      M      R      W
W Pilch                     54     24     71      3
Daplyn                       6      0     20      1
F Pilch                     26     10     37      1
Spinks                      24      9     36      1

Norfolk 1st innings
M Daplyn                                 b Hattersley           0
W Pilch                                  b Hattersley          30
O Laws                                   b Marsden              2
F Pilch               c Marsden                                 2
N Pilch                                  b Marsden              7
E Hogg                                   b Hattersley           2
T Roberts             not out                                  13
A Spinks              run out                                   0
+W Roberts                               b Hattersley          12
G Englebright                            b Marsden              0
Howard                hit wkt                                   0
Extras                (b 1, w 6)                                7
Total                 (all out, 63 overs)                      75

FoW: 1-?, 2-?, 3-?, 4-?, 5-?, 6-?, 7-?, 8-?, 9-?, 10-75.

Bowling                      O      M      R      W
Marsden                     33     11     44      3
Hattersley                  30     15     25      4

Yorkshire 2nd innings
J McCoy                                  b W Pilch             24
F Barlow              c Daplyn                                 22
T Marsden             st W.Roberts                             34
WH Woolhouse                             b W Pilch             13
E Vincent             c Spinks                                 36
G Smith                                  b Hogg                37
G Hattersley          not out                                  26
G Rawlins             c Englebright                             4
J Woollen                                b F Pilch             12
J Hydes               c N.Pilch                                20
J Dearman                                b F Pilch             12
Extras                (b 35, w 21)                             56
Total                 (all out, 144 overs)                    296

FoW: 1-?, 2-?, 3-?, 4-?, 5-?, 6-?, 7-?, 8-?, 9-?, 10-296.

Bowling                      O      M      R      W
W Pilch                     54     19     97      2
Daplyn                      31     13     44      0
F Pilch                     26     10     38      2
Spinks                      12      5     15      0
N Pilch                      5      3      5      0
T Roberts                    7      2     16      0
Hogg                         9      4     20      1

Norfolk 2nd innings (target: 413 runs)
E Hogg                c Hattersley                             22
T Roberts                                b Rawlins             15
F Pilch               not out                                 153
A Spinks                                 b Hattersley          32
M Daplyn                                 b Rawlins             17
+W Roberts                               b Rawlins              7
W Pilch                                  b Marsden              5
N Pilch                                  b Hattersley           0
Extras                (b 27, w 11)                             38
Total                 (7 wickets, 149 overs)                  289

DNB: O Laws, G Englebright, Howard.

FoW: 1-?, 2-?, 3-?, 4-?, 5-?, 6-?, 7-289.

Bowling                      O      M      R      W
Marsden                     42     10     94      1
Hattersley                  71     32    107      2
Rawlins                     33     13     48      3
Woollen                      3      0     16      0

• Rain stopped play on the 5th day and Norfolk conceded the match. 'It was given up in favour of Sheffield and the stakes handed over as the three players to go in were some of the worst bats of their party. They had no chance of winning.' Vincent batted from 1.00 to 6.15 on the first day, and F.Pilch's innings commenced at 1.00pm on the 4th day and continued until the end of the game. The Sheffield papers describe the match as Sheffield v Norfolk.
• It is not known which Roberts took the catch - assumed to be W
• The bowling does not add up correctly in three of the innings